Playing for a Nickel
January 6th, 2009College football’s champion will be decided this week with the Bowl Championship Series. Those of us from North Country realize that this is a sideline compared to the old tradition of awarding the Nickel Trophy between the winner of the football game that used to take place every year between North Dakota State University and the University of North Dakota.
UND was the traditional liberal arts university with the schools of medicine and law. NDSU started as the agriculture and engineering school. Only seventy-five miles apart, there was no end to intra-state snarling and barbs back and forth. One of the top college rivalries of all time as determined by several national surveys, on and off the field, the Nickel Trophy was the heart of the conflict between North Dakota State (the Bison) and the University of North Dakota (the Fighting Sioux).
The buffalo head nickel, with the mighty bison on one side and the image of a Sioux warrior on the other side is the perfect traveling trophy. The trophy wasn’t an actual nickel - this one was special. Minted in 1937, it weighs 75 lbs, is 2 inches thick, and almost 2 feet across.
Try putting that in a vending machine.
At UND, the Nickel is shepherded by their student government. At NDSU, the Nickel resides in the custody of the Blue Key National Honor Fraternity - a group dedicated to service to their fellow man (motto: Serving I Live), though the group is also a focal point for school spirit.
The annual game between the two rivals came to an end in 2004 as the Bison moved up to Division I-AA athletics to meet the needs of a fast growing campus and demands from alumni hungry to build a better program and the Sioux chose to stay in Division II (at least for a few more years).
The Nickel Trophy went back and forth 65 times starting in 1938, with UND holding a slight edge in wins (35 to NDSU’s 30 - though as a proud member of the Thundering Herd, I hate to admit that fact).
The unofficial transfer tally of the trophy would be much higher.
There was the famous (infamous?) time that the Nickel was stolen from UND and pictures were sent for the next several months to the Fargo Forum. The Nickel trophy in a tractor seat. The Nickel trophy in front of Mount Rushmore. The Nickel trophy in the Rockies. The Nickel Trophy in front of the Golden Gate Bridge. Then it vanished…until the Governor of the State of North Dakota got a 75 lb package shipped to him COD from California.
Yup, the Nickel was back.
Then there was the time that several NDSU students in maintenance garb managed to get the Nickel out of the trophy room at UND (essentially a locked vault in the athletic department) and smuggle it back to Fargo in time for homecoming.
That was the year that as a member of the homecoming court, I got to hold the Nickel at an after hour party…
UND had their moments too - ripping it off of the wall of the NDSU Student Union late at night.
As UND now makes the move to Division I-AA athletics, hopefully the rivalry and the tradition will be renewed.
Plus, since UND won the last football game, would be great to get it back down to NDSU where it belongs.